Seven Minutes, Nine Weeks: The Reign of "Hey Jude"
In 1968, the pop single was a disciplined little machine. Two and a half minutes, maybe three if the fade ran long. Program directors liked it that way, since shorter records meant more songs an hour, and the whole economy of Top 40 radio ran on that arithmetic. A four-minute record was a liability. A seven-minute one was a joke.
Then the Beatles handed radio exactly that: "Hey Jude," a piano ballad that runs a little over seven minutes, more than half of it without a single verse. Just that chant, na-na-na, over and over, gathering force each time around. By any rule of the format it was unplayable. Radio played it anyway, na-na-nas and all. Constantly. For months.
The Wrong Length on Purpose
The nerve of it still gets me. You could fit two ordinary hits inside "Hey Jude" and have room left over for the news. And the Beatles didn't tuck the excess away at the end of an album side where only the faithful would find it. They pressed it onto a single, the most commercial object pop music makes, and dared stations to cut it down.
A certain school of thought holds that the na-na-nas overstay their welcome. That school is wrong. The first half of "Hey Jude" is a lovely song; the long coda is why it's immortal. Paul McCartney's voice frays into screams while the orchestra piles on, and the chant simply refuses to end. Somewhere in there the record stops being a performance and turns into a crowd.
Underneath all that scale sits something small and genuinely tender. McCartney wrote the song to comfort Julian Lennon, John's young son, while Julian's parents were coming apart. It began as "Hey Jules," a kindness aimed at one boy in a hard year. "Take a sad song and make it better" was advice for one child before it became a chorus for millions.
And 1968 was a hard year for far more people than Julian. Martin Luther King was killed in April, Robert Kennedy in June. Vietnam led every newscast. I don't think it's an accident that the biggest record of that autumn was seven minutes of somebody insisting, patiently and then at the top of his lungs, that things can be made better. People needed the length. The song gave them time to start believing it.
Nine Weeks at Number One
The chart run matched the running time. "Hey Jude" reached #1 on the Hot 100 the week of September 28, 1968, taking the top spot from Jeannie C. Riley's "Harper Valley P.T.A.," which had been enjoying a remarkable moment of its own. Then it stopped moving. It was on top before the Tigers and the Cardinals had played a single game of that October's World Series, and it was still on top more than two weeks after Nixon won in November. Nine consecutive weeks in all, September 28 through November 23, the heart of an American autumn spent with one song on the chart's highest shelf. In a year as crowded as 1968, that kind of tenancy was almost rude.
No other Beatles record in this archive held the top that long. Not even the singles behind their April 1964 takeover of the entire top five, with Beatlemania at full boil and the country losing its collective mind, managed a reign like this. Four years after the screaming, their longest stay at #1 belonged to a slow one.
Widen the lens and it gets stranger. Across the whole of the 1960s in this archive, exactly one record matched a nine-week stay at #1: Percy Faith's "The Theme From 'A Summer Place,'" the plush instrumental that ruled back in 1960. So the decade that gave us the British Invasion, Motown, and psychedelia handed its two great endurance runs to a melody with no words and a ballad whose most famous stretch has none either. Make of that what you will.
Apple's Opening Statement
"Hey Jude" carried one more piece of freight: it was the first single out on Apple Records, the label the Beatles had just started for themselves. Consider what that meant. Every copy sold was now an advertisement for their business as much as their band, and the record they chose to lead with broke the format's most basic rule. That's either supreme confidence or total indifference to how things were done, and with the Beatles in 1968 those were usually the same thing.
It's hard to imagine a better proof of concept. The first record out under their own imprint became their longest-reigning #1 in this archive, and the well ran so deep that year that the flip side was "Revolution." Plenty of stars have launched vanity labels since, and most of those launches are footnotes. This one opened with a nine-week #1. If you're going to hang out a shingle, that's how you do it.
Motown Takes It Back
Every reign ends, and the way this one ended is my favorite detail in the whole story. The record that finally knocked "Hey Jude" off the top was "Love Child" by Diana Ross and the Supremes. Motown, the great American singles machine of the decade, reached up and took the #1 spot back from the band that had crashed its party four years earlier.
How do you follow nine weeks of na-na-na? With something that sounds nothing like it. "Love Child" was the Supremes at their toughest, a hit about poverty and a child born outside marriage, about as close to social realism as mainstream pop got in 1968. After two months of communal comfort, the chart pivoted to three minutes of hard truth. Say what you want about the Hot 100 as a document; it writes better scene changes than most screenwriters.
Still. Nine weeks. In a business engineered to turn hits over as quickly as possible, one seven-minute song planted itself at the top from late September until nearly Thanksgiving and would not budge. It's hard to take the format's stopwatch seriously after that. And whenever a stadium full of strangers carries that coda on its own, long after the band has dropped away, the old argument gets settled one more time. Radio worried that seven minutes was too long. More than half a century on, the song still hasn't ended.
Charts mentioned in this story
More stories from the archive
Explore the numbers behind this story in the full chart archive.